Politicians dominate the BBC airwaves

New research about the BBC’s news coverage, covered on The Conversation website, might explain why we are all growing increasingly keen to see crowd-sourced news – videos, blogs and photos from ‘citizen journalists’.

The research, conducted by Cardiff University and funded by the BBC Trust was designed to see whether the BBC is as impartial as it is supposed to be and whether the BBC critics’ claims of ‘left wing bias’ have any foundation.  But what it uncovered was more complex and perhaps more interesting:

  • There is a growing dominance of party political sources. For example, in the coverage of the European Union, party political sources accounted for 56% of source appearances in 2007 and 79.2% in 2012.  The coverage saw Europe almost exclusively through the prism of political infighting between Labour and the Conservatives so a rounded debate about the multiplicity of ways the relationship between the EU and UK affects Britain was almost completely absent.
  • Very few organisations other than politicians get a look in. On the issues of immigration and the EU in 2012, for example, out of 806 source appearances, not one was allocated to a representative of organised labour. As the researchers point out, ‘considering the impact of the issues on the UK workforce, and the fact that trade unions represent the largest mass democratic organisations in civil society, such invisibility raises troubling questions for a public service broadcaster committed to impartial and balanced coverage’.

In a period where the most progressive journalists are arguing for journalism as a conversation, The Guardian says the public is the most important media influence, and public cynicism about politicians is rife, this Westminster dominance by the BBC needs to be seriously reviewed.

And they also found that Conservative politicians are on our screens in greater numbers than Labour.

There is a lot more in the report in The Conversation website – take a look it is definitely worth a read.

 

 

The dark side of ‘Fifty Shades of Grey’

Esther Gaytan Fuertes writes: According to a recent study published by the Journal of Women’s Health, the novels Fifty Shades of Grey and its two sequels portray an abusive relationship characterised by the woman’s intimidation and isolation, where BDSM is the main ingredient. Researchers from the Michigan State University and the Ohio State University analysed the behaviours described in the best-seller in which the young literature student, Anastasia Steele, gets involved in a complex relationship with the powerful and dominating millionaire Christian Grey.

The paper, provocatively titled Double Crap!” Abuse and Harmed Identity in Fifty Shades of Grey’, mainly focuses on the first part of E. L. James’ Fifty Shades trilogy, and identifies and describes patterns in Christian’s behaviour consistent with Intimate Partner Violence (IPV); and Anastasia’s responses which are consistent with women’s experiences of abuse. Their analysis draws some interesting and worrying conclusions: ‘it is clear that right from the beginning, Christian controls all aspects of the couple’s relationship using the emotional abuse tactics of stalking, isolation, intimidation/threats, and humiliation (…) Anastasia becomes disempowered and entrapped in the relationship as her behaviours become mechanised in response to Christian’s abuse’. There is a significant power imbalance and the couple’s behaviours are typical of people in chronically violent relationships.

One of the most alarming conclusions of this study is that the behaviours depicted in the book “reflect pervasive IPV—one of the biggest problems of our time. Further, our analysis adds to a growing body of literature noting dangerous violence standards being perpetuated in popular culture.” If that is the case, it makes it even more astonishing that the majority of fans of this book, which epitomises the so-called phenomenon of “mummy porn”, are women. Arguably, we still need feminism to raise more general awareness of how even in escapist literature abused female characters perpetuate women’s disempowered role in our society.

 

Image courtesy of sattva / FreeDigitalPhotos.net

 

Yemen: more than just militancy

Victor Ponsford writes:  Yemen has a complex and colourful history and society, and its politics reflect this.  The media, however, are often guilty of reducing Yemen, along with its recondite culture, into one easily understood word: ‘terrorism’. Over the last ten days, a number of pieces from the BBC and other broadcasters and newspapers have reflected this one-dimensional view. Indeed, during the early days of the story, many reputable news sites were using a single source for the information: the US and UK governments’ travel advice and warnings.

A recent article by Atiaf Zaid Alwazir, a researcher and blogger based in Yemen, takes issue with this flawed media narrative. She argues that the portrayal of Yemen in international news does not reflect the actual experience of Yemenis in the country. She says this is most obvious when a big news item about a terrorist is published and most Yemenis haven’t heard of him. Perhaps this is because for Yemenis terrorism is not the biggest story. As Yemen has succeeded in forcing its ruler of 33 years – Ali Abdullah Salah – out of office, the most important topic is: ‘How do we move forward?’

Flag_of_Yemen.svgFor Yemenis themselves, this week’s biggest story is the army mutiny that took place a few days ago outside the presidential palace, rather than the closure of the US embassy. Reports vary widely: some sources suggest it was an attempted coup, as in Egypt, while others say that it was the former president flexing his muscles. Still others report that it was born from a sense of frustration when the Ramadan bonus, usually provided by Saudi Arabia, was not paid this year. Whatever the case, it barely made headlines or even featured on the websites of Western news outlets, compared with the coverage of the coup in Egypt, for example. Where it did feature, however, it was inevitably a body-count story with little analysis about the implications of the mutiny on Yemeni society.

Over the last few days, particularly, the pictures, films and stories about the capital, Sana’a and Yemen describe a city and a country on the brink of a terrorist uprising. Yet, what one actually hears from Yemenis themselves is that the streets, due to the arrival of Eid, have been bustling with people purchasing gifts and food. Indeed, one man that I recently interviewed spent a good five minutes complaining about the traffic and wishing for rain so that the streets would become less congested. The fact that the average Yemeni is out on the street and finding the time to complain about the traffic is in opposition to the view of “Fortress Sana’a”.

While I was finishing off this blog piece, the BBC posted a story about a drone strike in Yemen, which mentioned the Eid celebrations. Initially, they used the following image of Yemeni children celebrating Eid.

BBC report of Yemenis enjoying Eid celebrations 2

I asked Angela Phillips, who runs the postgraduate journalism programme at Goldsmith University to comment:

“[The] use of that particular image is a crude stereotype. Little boys in every country play with guns. The use of it to illustrate this particular story suggests a culture in which little boys are encouraged to ape the behaviour of militants. It is easy to see why it was used – it seems to ‘go with’ the story but in fact it distorts the story. Al Qaeda by all accounts have little support in Yemen so this picture is positively misleading.”

We need to be better served by our media if we are fully to understand the complexities of the modern world.

Reluctant to get your plates out?

Walking through the centre of London on a hot July afternoon this year, I noticed a couple of women wearing summery dresses each sporting a pair of winter boots. Probably another fashion that has passed me by, I mused.  But perhaps I should think again: recent research from The College of Podiatry suggests that, with 1 in 5 UK women being embarrassed about their feet, 12 percent resort to covering them up on a sunny day because they don’t like how they look.

So exactly what probelms are causing this anxiety? Top of the list comes the painful blister (55%), followed by cracked heels (45%), veruccas (28%), corns (24%) and ingrown toenails (20%). Apparently, twice the number of women to men report suffering from corns, cracked heels and bunions. Despite these problems, 19 per cent of women haven’t sought help because they didn’t think their foot complaint was important.

Why do more women suffer than men? Not unexpectedly, fashion does feature as a cause of some of these problems, for both sexes, but the survey results showed that twice as many women put up with discomfort and pain, with 43 per cent admitting they have continued to wear uncomfortable shoes even though they hurt their feet. A third (36%) of women, compared with just 12 per cent of men, have worn shoes they knew didn’t fit them because they looked nice.

IMG_3074When it comes to footwear, UK women have an average of 17 pairs of shoes compared to 8 pairs for the average male. When wearing high heels, on average it takes 1 hour, 6 minutes and 48 seconds for their feet to start hurting. One in five say they start to feel pain within just 10 minutes. A third of women (37 per cent) say they have walked home with no shoes on after a night out because their feet hurt and 28 per cent have danced bare foot while on a night out because of foot pain.

Age is also a factor. The younger the woman, the higher the heel worn, with 20 per cent of women aged 18-24 owning a pair of six inch high heeled shoes compared to 10 per cent of those aged 25-42 and just 3 per cent of 35-44 year olds.

In a separate survey, podiatrists indicated that the biggest cause of foot problems in the UK is footwear, with a lack of public awareness of common foot complaints also contributing to the problem. Lorraine Jones, podiatrist from The College of Podiatry said: “It’s shocking how little regard we show for our feet. Feet are one of the hardest working parts of the body and in a lifetime you will walk in excess of 150,000 miles. As a result of general wear and tear, most of us will suffer with some sort of foot complaint at some point in our lives but we are seeing a lot of cases which could have been prevented, particularly amongst women.

Conditions like blisters and cracked heels may sound like minor ailments, but they can cause a lot of discomfort and embarrassment. Many people don’t seek treatment early enough which means they suffer unnecessarily and their problems get worse. We all like to look good but it’s important to take a common sense approach to footwear. High heels and flip-flops are fine to wear occasionally but not all the time. For day to day wear you should opt for a well-fitting round toed shoe with a heel height of around 3cm.”

feet
Here’s a list of the top ten foot problems suffered by women:
1.    Blisters (55%)
2.    Cracked heels (45%)
3.    Veruccas (28%)
4.    Corns (24%)
5.    Ingrown toe nails (20%) and  Athletes foot (20%)
6.    Bunions (13%)
7.    Joint problems (11%)
8.    Excessive foot odour (9%)
9.    Arthritis (8.8%)
10.  Muscular problems (8%)

Putting the fish in ‘selfish’

The law of the jungle can be harsh, but the law of the river is even worse judging by the newly observed behaviour of a fish that attacks the weakest member of the shoal when danger is spotted – leaving it stunned to be gobbled up by predators.

It’s well known that fish gather in shoals to reduce their chances of being eaten by predators, but on a project in Brazil, Professor Robert Young from Salford University’s School of Environment & Life Sciences noticed that, when threatened by a predatory fish, a group of two-spot astyanax will turn on one of its members – biting and ramming it.

The unfortunate fish is then left stunned in the water for a few seconds – easy meat for a predator – while its treacherous fellows get away.

Professor Young first noticed the unique behaviour when trying to find ways of keeping the fish out of hydroelectric machinery in Brazil’s rivers.  Intrigued by this extremely rare response to an attack, he investigated further and the results have just been published in the journal Animal Behaviour.

Alongside colleague Vinícius Goulart of the Pontifical Catholic University of Minas Gerais in Belo Horizonte, Brazil, he took eight groups of eight astynax back to the lab for further study.  The fish were exposed to mock attacks – one from a bird, one from an ambush by a fish from a plastic tube, and a slow approach from a model of a predatory trahira fish.

The backstabbing behaviour only showed during the approach from the trahira –leading Professor Young to conclude that the fish only turn on each other when in a situation where one will be selected by a predator for attack.

This behaviour has never been seen before and arises, Professor Young believes, because of the small size of the shoals.  “In an attack each of the fish has a one in eight chance of being attacked, so this behaviour helps with the odds,” he said.  “This hasn’t been observed before, possibly because most social animals tend to punish members of the group which break rules. However, in the case of the astynax, treachery appears to be tolerated and all of the members of the group are happy enough to join in.  It’s rough luck for the victim, but in the wild it helps ensure that the more ruthless members of the shoal can stay alive and breed.”

Who is giving financial support to people in poverty?

Research suggests that during times of financial crisis, individuals and households return to forgotten and (previously) redundant forms of economic and social behaviour in order to survive.

Given governments’ emphasis, over the past 15 years, on credit unions as a way of supporting those on very low incomes it is perhaps surprising that recent research by Dr Lee Gregory of Bristol University suggests that both credit unions and time banks have been slow to respond to the current crisis.

PSE (Poverty and Social Exclusion) says that over 30 million people are financially insecure so there may still be a role for credit unions within government policy. Yet data for 2011 shows that, with just under 1 million members, credit unions provide only a relatively minor 2.4% penetration into the UK population.

Could it be that payday loan sharks are the ‘forgotten and (previously) redundant forms of economic and social behaviour’ that people are turning to in order to survive?   – credit unions and time banks take note!

Monitoring the globe

The global ‘space market’ is predicted to be worth $400bn by 2030.     The cost of putting satellites into orbit is expected to fall dramatically over the next decade – so there is likely to be a scramble to monitor the globe.  Britain wants 10% of that market and university scientists are being enlisted to ensure we achieve it.

Scientists at the Universities of Surrey and Reading will work with colleagues at the National Physical Laboratory (NPL) in the new collaboration called Global Satellite Sensing (GLOSS) – a world leading Centre of Excellence to monitor changes to the Earth, its ecosystem and climate.

The aim is to develop ways of using the very latest advances in the new generation of small, lightweight and highly innovative satellites, being developed in the UK to provide new satellite data services for meteorological purposes and use in disaster scenarios, as well as proving a wide range of services to commercial sectors, including energy resource management, urban and environmental monitoring, security and insurance industries.

It involves everything from developing new low cost sensors and designing groups of small satellites (called ‘swarms’) that can work together to in-orbit calibration systems, data assimilation, data processing and visualisation.

Professor Robert Gurney, Director of Space and Earth Observation at the University of Reading, which has the largest research capability in weather and climate science and earth observation of any university in Europe, says,

“British scientists are among the best in the world at using data from satellites to provide vital information about weather and climate. By helping to develop the next generation of satellite technology, this collaboration will help to expand the range of information available to businesses and industry, such as real-time data. Such crucial and affordable information will help to give British businesses the cutting edge, boosting innovation and economic growth.”

We’d all welcome more accurate weather forecasting, of course.  But coming hot on the heels of the NSA/Edward Snowden revelations, we can perhaps be excused for feeling concerned about the levels of surveillance we are likely to experience over the coming years….

The dance WE made

A few weeks ago I spent an amazing afternoon in the company of the dancer and choreographer Tim Casson who pitched up in a London street and asked passers-by to create dances for him to perform.

The Dance we madeThis is street dance with a difference!  Tim’s project The dance WE made which is supported by Big Dance, The Arts Council, The Swarm, Lottery, Sadlers Wells, Mayor of London and Camper gives a new perspective on the locations and spaces where the dance is imagined and performed.

You can subscribe to The dance WE made YouTube channel where you’ll find film of the street choreographers at work and of Tim dancing in Leicester Square, Exmouth Market, Trafalgar Square and the Barbican – as well as Glastonbury and New York.

Tess Woodcraft

Asylum seekers: written out of the picture

A new report, ‘Written out of the picture‘, published this week by the North East Child Poverty Commission and the Regional Refugee Forum North East draws attention to the destitution suffered by many refugees and asylum seekers, and points to their reliance on local services – libraries, health centres etc

Asylum seekers are not allowed to work whilst their claims are being determined, and most depend on Section 95 support, which is a lower rate of support than for UK citizens who are unable to work.  It often works out at just over £5 a day (housing and utility bills are paid for separately).

According to researchers, asylum seekers ‘are forced to live on the ‘margins of the margins’ while waiting for their cases to be processed. Cut off from the world of work, and often denied decent housing, adequate medical provision or cultural services, many drift into a state of destitution, rely on charity hand-outs or are forced into an underground economy.‘(O’Neill & Hubbard)

Despite a growing acknowledgement that the support offered to asylum seekers in the UK effectively ‘traps’ them in poverty, the role of local services and the issue of poverty amongst individuals once  granted leave to remain has received little attention from researchers or campaigners.  Given the importance of these services to the lives of asylum seekers, they should be a key group who are consulted on how services are provided.  Instead they are often patronised or ignored.

The report includes a number of recommendations that local services may want to consider but the over-riding aim is to encourage service providers to start a discussion ‘with’ asylum seekers and refugees about their experiences of poverty, rather than continue a somewhat limited discussion ‘about’ them and/or ‘without’ them.

Thanks:

We were alerted to this report by Poverty and Social Exclusion, the academic network for those working on poverty issues.